Practice Competence & Excellence
The Practice Competence and Excellence (PCE) dimension focuses on the attitudes and activities that comprise our direct clinical care of sick, injured or vulnerable people. It emphasises the objective, procedural aspects of nursing practice which are carried out at least with competence and always with the intent of developing excellence.
The PCE dimension is broadly similar to the widely recognised nursing process but its concepts are understood and implemented with renewed meaning and in greater depth. Most of its concepts emphasise the outward life or bio-physical reality of body and senses, but its concepts also encompass the inward life of mind and spirit as they are directly related to skilled clinical practice.
In the following diagram of Careful Nursing, PCE is shown in the blue coloured section which is emphasised. Analysis of the historical documents from which Careful Nursing was constructed revealed that most content described the nurses' direct care of sick, injured and vulnerable people in hospitals and communities. The data strongly suggested competence as the best descriptor of their clinical practice because they assessed patients' needs and their personal, social and economic situations comprehensively; were organized, innovative, clear and confident about the care to be provided; were invariably calm, kind and patient in manner; were adroit at managing the community and organizational circumstances in which they were practicing; and were able to adjust quickly and appropriately to sudden changes and emergency situations.
The 19th century nurses were widely respected for their nursing practice ability, even by people who were very opposed to their culture and spiritual beliefs. The historical data also suggested that the nurses' ultimate practice aspiration was excellence. They viewed excellence as using their knowledge and ingenuity to create the very best possible overall circumstances to promote patient safety and healing. Ultimately, excellence included fostering and recognising moments of transcendent love, peace and joy that could emerge for patients in the flow of human healing relationships.
Literature on competence indicates that there are different views on the nature of competence (Fernandez et al. 2012) and suggests that competence and excellence relate to one another on a continuum that can move in either direction. A nurse's position on this continuum may be influenced by a range of personal and situational factors. We know the experience and satisfaction of being close to excellence but we also have times when we are more in the area of competence. Nonetheless we all aspire together and help one another to practice with excellence.
The purpose of PCE is four-fold:
♦ foster excellence in clinical practice
♦ support and strengthen nurses control over their practice and practice environment
♦ enable nurses to articulate their practice clearly in the collaborative, multidisciplinary healthcare team
♦ make the nursing profession's distinctive contribution in healthcare visible
The eight PCE concepts
The PCE dimension is defined operationally by its eight concepts which fall loosely into three groups, as shown in the Figure below.
To the left of the Figure, Great tenderness in all things and "Perfect" skill in fostering safety and comfort provide the underlying context for implementation of the additional six concepts.
At the center of the Figure, the circle of four blue concepts form a critical circle of clinical responsibility. The critical circle of clinical responsibility is defined as the nursing process in Careful Nursing. The nursing process is widely considered to include five steps; assessment, diagnosis, planning, implementation and evaluation. In the critical circle of clinical responsibility the first step of the nursing process is represented by watching-assessment-recognition and the remaining four steps are represented by clinical reasoning and decision-making, patient engagement in self-care and diagnosis-outcomes-interventions.
To the right of the Figure, family, friends, community supportive participation and health education support the critical circle of clinical responsibility concepts.
The PCE responsibility for identifying collaborative problems
In the Figure above you will also see collaborative problems in the red circle. For as long as healthcare has existed, nursing and medicine have collaborated closely, each to bring its own distinctive expertise to meet patients' healing needs. This collaboration is recognised in the multidisciplinary collaborative practice of the healthcare team. There is also an especially close and acute collaboration between nursing and medicine represented in the identification and monitoring of collaborative problems (Carpenito 2017); "Certain physiologic complications that nurses monitor to detect onset or change in status." (p. 22). Collaborative problems are not part of Careful Nursing in itself but are closely associated with Careful Nursing, as indicated in the Figure above.
The PCE incorporation of evidence-based standardised nursing languages
A prominent feature of PCE is the incorporation of the standardised nursing languages of NANDA-I nursing diagnosis (Herdman & Kamitsuru 2018), the Nursing Outcomes Classification (Moorhead et al. 2018), and Nursing Interventions Classification (Butcher et al. 2018). These languages, shown in the Figure above, provide nurses with the ability to name and measure their distinctive practice responsibilities, that is, to diagnose and treat undesirable human responses or susceptibility to such responses to health (illness) conditions or life processes and, in addition, to make health promotion diagnoses.
These standardised nursing languages provide the best contemporary interpretation of the 19th century nurses practice; the 19th century nurses clearly identified nursing problems, developed and provided a range of nursing interventions and evaluated their effectiveness. In effect, their work prefigured the development of standardised nursing languages.
Nurses distinctive, visible role in the multidisciplinary team providing collaborative care
The Figure below shows how nurses take their place in the multidisciplinary team with confidence and engage in collaborative practice with other healthcare disciplines. Each discipline's contribution to patient care is recognised and respected. It should be noted that Careful Nursing does not engage primarily in integrated or interdisciplinary care. In an integrated or interdisciplinary care process several professional disciplines' care is combined to address patient problems and nursing is invariably rendered invisible and taken for granted.
Butcher HK, Bulechek GM, Dochterman JM & Wagner CM (Eds.) (2018) Nursing Interventions Classification (NIC) (7th ed.). St. Louis, MO: Elsevier.
Carpenito LJ. (2017) Nursing Diagnosis: Application to Clinical Practice (15th ed.). Philadelphia: Wolters Kluwer.
Fernandez N, Dory V, Ste-Marie L, Chaput M, Charlin B. & Boucher A. (2012). Varying conceptions of competence: an analysis of how health sciences educators define competence. Medical Education, 46, 357-365.
Herdman TH, & Kamitsuru S (Eds.) (2018). Nursing Diagnoses Definitions and Classifications 2018–2020. New York, NY: Thieme Publishers
Moorhead S, Swanson E, Johnson M, & Maas M, (Eds.) (2018). Nursing Outcomes Classification (NOC): Measurement of Health Outcomes (6th ed.). St. Louis, MO: Elsevier.
Therese C. Meehan ©